From fbfcde34565ab7e01c0fd1bb93ea35801b55f941 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Adrien VALLETTE Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 10:47:35 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?T=C3=A9l=C3=A9verser=20les=20fichiers=20vers=20?= =?UTF-8?q?"td4"?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit --- td4/TD4_script.R | 206 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ td4/Tennis-Sleep.dta | Bin 0 -> 8578 bytes td4/hprice1.dta | Bin 0 -> 4922 bytes 3 files changed, 206 insertions(+) create mode 100644 td4/TD4_script.R create mode 100644 td4/Tennis-Sleep.dta create mode 100644 td4/hprice1.dta diff --git a/td4/TD4_script.R b/td4/TD4_script.R new file mode 100644 index 0000000..180c00a --- /dev/null +++ b/td4/TD4_script.R @@ -0,0 +1,206 @@ +#----------------------------------------------------------# +#--- TD4 : regressions sur donnees reelles, biais de ------# +#--- variable omise, tests ------# +#----------------------------------------------------------# + +library(haven) # read_dta : lire les fichiers Stata (.dta) +library(estimatr) # lm_robust : regression + se robustes +library(car) # linearHypothesis : tests de Wald +library(lmtest) # coeftest : test sur un coefficient +library(ggplot2) # graphiques + +# Parametres ---- +dossier <- "td4/" # dossier des fichiers .dta (a adapter) +se_type <- "HC0" # se robuste du cours ; "stata" = HC1, + # chiffres du corrige commun + +#----------------------------------------------------------# +#--- Exercice 1 : le sommeil et le tennis -----------------# +#----------------------------------------------------------# + +tennis <- read_dta(file.path(dossier, "Tennis-Sleep.dta")) + +# ---------- Q1 : statistiques descriptives ---------------- + +# (la colonne Date est du texte : on la retire) +summary(tennis[, -1]) + +# P1 contre P2 : jeux gagnes, sommeil, alcool (moyennes) +data.frame(joueur = c("P1", "P2"), + jeux = c(mean(tennis$GamesP1), mean(tennis$GamesP2)), + sommeil = c(mean(tennis$SleepP1), mean(tennis$SleepP2)), + alcool = c(mean(tennis$AlcoholP1), + mean(tennis$AlcoholP2))) + +# ---------- Q2 : DifgamesP1P2 sur SleepP1 ----------------- + +reg1 <- lm_robust(DifgamesP1P2 ~ SleepP1, data = tennis, + se_type = se_type) +summary(reg1) + +# Memes tests avec la loi normale du cours +# (summary affiche des p-valeurs de Student : meme conclusion) +coeftest(reg1, df = Inf) + +# ---------- Q3 : signe du biais de variable omise --------- + +# Cours (chap. 1, prop. 4) : beta_court = beta_long + lambda * beta_G +# lambda = coef. de SleepP1 dans la regression de AlcoholP1 sur SleepP1 +lambda <- coef(lm(AlcoholP1 ~ SleepP1, data = tennis))["SleepP1"] +c(correlation = cor(tennis$SleepP1, tennis$AlcoholP1), + lambda = unname(lambda)) + +# ---------- Q4 : on ajoute AlcoholP1 ---------------------- + +reg2 <- lm_robust(DifgamesP1P2 ~ SleepP1 + AlcoholP1, + data = tennis, se_type = se_type) +summary(reg2) + +# La formule du cours est exacte sur l'echantillon +biais <- lambda * coef(reg2)["AlcoholP1"] +c(beta_court = unname(coef(reg1)["SleepP1"]), + beta_long = unname(coef(reg2)["SleepP1"]), + biais = unname(biais)) + +# ---------- Q5 : SleepP2 et AlcoholP2 --------------------- + +# Peu correlees avec SleepP1 et AlcoholP1 : pas de biais +round(cor(tennis[, c("SleepP1", "AlcoholP1", + "SleepP2", "AlcoholP2")]), 2) + +# ---------- Q6 : regression complete ---------------------- + +reg3 <- lm_robust(DifgamesP1P2 ~ SleepP1 + AlcoholP1 + + SleepP2 + AlcoholP2, + data = tennis, se_type = se_type) +summary(reg3) +coeftest(reg3, df = Inf) + +# Test de significativite globale : les 4 coefficients sont nuls +linearHypothesis(reg3, c("SleepP1 = 0", "AlcoholP1 = 0", + "SleepP2 = 0", "AlcoholP2 = 0"), + test = "Chisq") + +# Le coefficient de SleepP1 selon les variables incluses +modeles <- list("SleepP1 seul" = reg1, + "+ AlcoholP1" = reg2, + "+ SleepP2, AlcoholP2" = reg3) +coef_sleep <- data.frame( + modele = factor(names(modeles), levels = rev(names(modeles))), + coef = sapply(modeles, function(m) coef(m)["SleepP1"]), + se = sapply(modeles, function(m) m$std.error["SleepP1"])) + +ggplot(coef_sleep, aes(x = coef, y = modele)) + + geom_vline(xintercept = 0, linetype = "dashed") + + geom_pointrange(aes(xmin = coef - 1.96 * se, + xmax = coef + 1.96 * se)) + + labs(title = expression("Coefficient de " * SleepP1 * + " et intervalle de confiance a 95 %"), + x = "Effet d'une heure de sommeil de P1 (en jeux)", + y = NULL) + + theme_minimal() + +# ---------- Q7 : meme effet du sommeil pour les deux ------ + +# H0 : beta1 = - beta3, soit R beta0 = 0 avec R = (0, 1, 0, 1, 0) +R <- c(0, 1, 0, 1, 0) +b <- 0 +linearHypothesis(reg3, hypothesis.matrix = R, rhs = b, + test = "Chisq") + +# Autre methode : theta = beta1 + beta3 devient un coefficient +# y = b0 + theta x1 + b2 x2 + g (x1 - x3) + b4 x4, avec g = - beta3 +tennis$DifsleepP1P2 <- tennis$SleepP1 - tennis$SleepP2 +reg3_bis <- lm_robust(DifgamesP1P2 ~ SleepP1 + DifsleepP1P2 + + AlcoholP1 + AlcoholP2, + data = tennis, se_type = se_type) +summary(reg3_bis) + +# Le test de H0 : theta = 0 est le test de SleepP1 (loi normale) +coeftest(reg3_bis, df = Inf)["SleepP1", ] + +#----------------------------------------------------------# +#--- Exercice 2 : les prix des logements ------------------# +#----------------------------------------------------------# + +hprice <- read_dta(file.path(dossier, "hprice1.dta")) + +# ---------- Q0 : statistiques descriptives ---------------- + +# price et assess en milliers de $, sqrft et lotsize en pieds carres +summary(hprice[, c("price", "assess", "bdrms", "lotsize", "sqrft")]) + +# ---------- Q1-Q2 : l'evaluation est-elle rationnelle ? --- + +# price = b0 + b1 assess + u ; H0 : b0 = 0 et b1 = 1 +reg_prix <- lm_robust(price ~ assess, data = hprice, + se_type = se_type) +summary(reg_prix) + +# Test joint : R = I2, b = (0, 1)' +R <- diag(2) +b <- c(0, 1) +linearHypothesis(reg_prix, hypothesis.matrix = R, rhs = b, + test = "Chisq") + +# Tests simples (pour une egalite : Chisq = z^2) +linearHypothesis(reg_prix, "(Intercept) = 0", test = "Chisq") +linearHypothesis(reg_prix, "assess = 1", test = "Chisq") + +# Pourquoi la difference ? Les deux estimateurs sont tres correles +V <- vcov(reg_prix) +V[1, 2] / sqrt(V[1, 1] * V[2, 2]) + +# Ellipse de confiance a 95 % pour (b0, b1) et rectangle forme +# par les deux intervalles a 95 % pris separement +centre <- coef(reg_prix) +t <- seq(0, 2 * pi, length.out = 200) +cercle <- cbind(cos(t), sin(t)) * sqrt(qchisq(0.95, df = 2)) +ellipse <- as.data.frame(sweep(cercle %*% chol(V), 2, centre, "+")) +names(ellipse) <- c("b0", "b1") +se <- sqrt(diag(V)) + +ggplot(ellipse, aes(x = b0, y = b1)) + + annotate("rect", fill = "grey85", + xmin = centre[1] - 1.96 * se[1], + xmax = centre[1] + 1.96 * se[1], + ymin = centre[2] - 1.96 * se[2], + ymax = centre[2] + 1.96 * se[2]) + + geom_path(linewidth = 1) + + annotate("point", x = centre[1], y = centre[2], size = 2) + + annotate("point", x = 0, y = 1, size = 3, colour = "red") + + annotate("text", x = 0, y = 1.03, colour = "red", + label = "H0 : (0, 1)") + + labs(title = expression("Region de confiance a 95 % pour (" * + beta[0] * ", " * beta[1] * ")"), + x = expression(beta[0]), y = expression(beta[1])) + + theme_minimal() + +# Ecart moyen evaluation - prix : la droite estimee passe par +# (assess moyen ; price moyen), l'evaluation est trop elevee +lm_robust(I(assess - price) ~ 1, data = hprice, se_type = se_type) + +# ---------- Q3 : effet d'une chambre de 150 pieds carres -- + +reg_log <- lm_robust(lprice ~ sqrft + bdrms, data = hprice, + se_type = se_type) +summary(reg_log) + +# Effet = 150 * b_sqrft + b_bdrms (modele log-niveau) +effet <- sum(c(0, 150, 1) * coef(reg_log)) +c(effet_en_log = effet, effet_en_pct = 100 * (exp(effet) - 1)) + +# ---------- Q4 : regression qui donne directement l'effet - + +# theta = 150 b1 + b2 donc b2 = theta - 150 b1 : +# lprice = b0 + b1 (sqrft - 150 bdrms) + theta bdrms + u +hprice$sqrft150b <- hprice$sqrft - 150 * hprice$bdrms +reg_theta <- lm_robust(lprice ~ sqrft150b + bdrms, data = hprice, + se_type = se_type) +summary(reg_theta) + +# Intervalle de confiance a 95 % (loi normale du cours) +theta_hat <- coef(reg_theta)["bdrms"] +se_theta <- reg_theta$std.error["bdrms"] +c(borne_basse = unname(theta_hat - 1.96 * se_theta), + borne_haute = unname(theta_hat + 1.96 * se_theta)) diff --git a/td4/Tennis-Sleep.dta b/td4/Tennis-Sleep.dta new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5ba086f322d905179bcd38475c17f010193e5c2b GIT binary patch literal 8578 zcmeHN&u<$=6n=J`#Azv%!U1k>Md3nO?>axx;!M>7f>tF`FGU=ZO|oe$Id!l%g-S@Q zkdWYjRQ1*iGB++rIRMwJ|AX9m;ouWOoN_BFNag$HhwTI*g-X;HPck0weDl5c=Ixs| zlih@^Bub*?^(3l>n{l)rH>+VYuE$X;uKNCb=(&q<^-dBunjCQT`a7Z5zYMQbrzG^Q zRKsi4_r#RYyH*YB(P~_;3NZ66Oln&(^lfcdpZDiWAFL&%pd17x-+!}G4!u4add`%s zXd41d`PQ~C=ggO@w*7tFT)!}3+SiJveejHFFTG^i4coqd)?9yR+uOGN!nUDDt>Nvc zS<d@p5u!J8o5r^6>E^{5-Tjj~<8Kks+kqiZI3MsdF$0foyWNdJr@et+Uh&;vfjs+O*|b(z-Y|K z10xTNJn+AIfP380y*{Po_Ajx@zJZ_ee>t%A_Z$w?nvAD<*Z`gjV~WuAoR5z z=-LbSe$aUOD}%P%jFHx@n8Ag$p7lIGy2b*-#)%~ ziL%n4{<_T8*>mEU`kbDXhLPj+Te{pY7=1l?KcCZjF>d5QI%(v$?&b2)L81MM#1lD3PO(I#TIpMQ%GxBI$wsgZ2P%};8rSVreS?dTis960dQ+a9gMwaus*ttD|250`3d zt!n7~qh}p28LC0x;n!b)z-)XHpBHUaXjLv)aB#XehD>?d!Ydk;fX3E{YE}JOkbBEDyJ2=pKLrunjEg z1YT_ra+4DgSXR+w5cAe+18fR6c$yW!rq>87Qz?89=A_zyU=~X-@8EVe4yO{zP{|f0 zkUed5_l5V|BDrA3;Yyvxy!S0TC0lX}UU|k@UgX~!(9LRLf7apcP64lOx~gw^x|j

)mmDnDbQq#Tv8{~df)?|h@et@`nc)S6Q!g!Nfo?>(#&M;Jc%?VqM7}8L!?@~+?j+^56A+n*y>R1!G-7g3s?(R zGQ;I|%(OdSRl4TQsY4rghy@-0*0dGOtSDCFrp>!%Cj0y7pDf`Hin>7yfSYozNL$&1}s;Ke$O#0 z8oboW1J2Mruu5>p;5gFLy$OUOt)}3V!}Kaa*45J0NyOSNy1S@%2@3<+!b%l#MmQB% zHYaUO+ncnjM8n!^NFEMWSsp2uP}i{`oRijc13Sp-M)I(*xuKjChpbRS6+UOE(Jh8e zn6(X9kg&lvxVa_lCYx=F`#taA{$8RbfGkX!3^fWjdx;aCDGejH^l&aBI+ak#z)*~N z1sK}an?;x1FfBDOsRkAyn-EjJh7m28nSs;20-x&uq6EvH^*A$`MTcHQ2Na4S3N0#x zYaFoNO9*GEnyrOfSk#2wL)#X{QV2XQaJ-Ea)e*ah$mS3QuT>0A-ID|JUePcUwx$b8 zKHqms3K+3A$8;XZ9NFX0ouPXlm2iqs)Vl#xV=PT`yWm~GD>!-hhK{j&MMNr@lwgJ9 nhHB{`XJgj1E?|WU-Jz#XH(@Jj)_M4`?Z87x_8z(H|J%jiokZYu literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/td4/hprice1.dta b/td4/hprice1.dta new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ba47dec50130ce22ee25507a3140f486dc2245e1 GIT binary patch literal 4922 zcmeHJc~p~E7Jm=2@ewqx2b?-)YQ?S9P~2Oc`~3K#L#;CI(iuyHM34wbptzx7R77#1 zQZ4RiTQ?BG4ze^-QEWw{Gi|kXZ>zX#-HXcHm*D7`BRz9G{yC2mc)Z{H-TmGdiyI{Z znMiPTea$TcKi0nl%k06yGKxnx0~6iOjYxFsv@nU-Kk|0-!!r$jipM0nko>?xN1i-sc=D*>39gvfh)^T35Hr91qGhmH zj1~(a+82TRY)V+{bPF-!PczFL9cPJ{ZERkGWk#$iju@IXfrLhzqoX2z=YrYgMl%NB zvH7VR&0R4+wX)d@E-RZik`POHgelGvXNWT@geYTzIU>qv=`ygFZYoK4N_FiO&+Y&C z++OM0yDmLgwIB1MC_WfQj1oul*awQu<8bUF*!<}Cz2_7)-vyoGU% z-h$5VElj`aEreBi3-8}Ty$A9~Y(ebenuI4v}X+JWU3`A#Ja{Indl^ligB zneQO}XVJf465`ga(quWwY`p`LhGs+Siz?Qo|3$<_vF^}R#O*7k9dbIYVh3yp$bp}4 zD%hEy>w#GJp#IIMe`b|*%!95wMNAuBn#3QqVT- zO5w!PV(3)m$%d`Jj`od2+|2DSmo6&Ey~JJ6>&G1E=jX{Th&K?A5ly~UZhs$Xijo)& zxnP@<2M%Q;^o+cP@>ht2Y()E!ul1mQ=L$jDP~zn8eft6O*P#6lw12=!DNu06x4(QZ zDE4`=AmI`6zefHEl;7vi`rcmjcqcm;##e(Sqdi;nh%!RPil%L;h@U+uMJh?Rh%Cr^ zrw|T)sAla~as3N1KPwS0{YFxGP~YYGP}!{r6pPfX>*@PoGKFG%!qGlQh;&v#H*Vhz zVUalyPuO?6ix3a8Ng;AN`BFZl?9GRPeFfH1!xj3TN=jChfY_@HD(-05 z;8`~jUxe{ZN4_mfA}UI<^I>p(5lpQ0VCNp8ezI6JnKmPCzb%bWQN3>gj7lhlA46NR zkgj(TH(>raKcif#SCIUm-4Opv5s3btY{_tLUwhOa#QpnB+NU7e37OEbZWj!?t72}M zJpTz;ztPAKXrs@R(@P_4;5#7~o=j`a5=(e}E)nb0T)yT@X_=CIT2TPm=Zj$EJWn>D z)33-kA)otiJIe7dWjR2<&xcVBY8P(J68&!%ATCqr2dSv-@E)*Dtbn8S8n)vc)~EeC z%D*8h3ApPIdeL)XHP9ov2BxNK*zf{3%zrNCKM(CM^wztps4lJ?M%^ffq{i0ljEeW4 z3Hxgj;<`0b7X{_|1N7N2?sFyUm3js3-!2lX9r4mgy_YBXz-tdYuvS6!Egv>z%oF6# z5$i^Tpncwj(qsi);IKi@{=1>`GJze)xr%rs*3TT|&paUMl=NC*4t#sf23ft-EM+C; z&sr$@TeyALf34BK85Pj(LbX-wS5S>KPeFJ0w1M9nh2ZO^X6ljGfP}mqu)W71S-rbAd7;+3=Uwi}>Kj_SA z_VfOniTO!E{Xr+CnF{I_WrMGm6u`b3FBYjoKIUhg&sdaS`-PM)bJmA^dKTOr;K7o7 z&SU(_u|D%~K7=2U?y9I^XC(|jS`OC3YPNjceZ&_ce=hPJcch;c&i)>E#|GK)Em=cf ztZ(ZEI;>@Pmw9K{k*(8aCtV0&sFEI24IUF~I*kMnbFD)O}s$>f@!)dLD4`=pxv^c}B{ zg;?JkkdO8kD(PEM`4IV_#A(0x0p1_;v3^o9{>!5D`{hJ6Iu9lW7Q*`1JFrvBE+IY| z^QY(fGbO8>CjB7`jN^AgP=$(xHS+nbvTKMm*KYSbT6 zDJ@dc$zzJZVJLY4g1YVr&5c+`(g`rHWK?6=cB(r*B_E4SryLtINqZO&e=WKg$dlg^_ZVT5hvSrX`0+Q zU$4KB2Z~@1W|)WZ%e;d1af{bif_|Vte|@kIO7m*qVMzxjecOQcZ^!uX`C$7^YUM%s ze9**J!IAH@XyN~%(2FS>RLHdybtxVky_m>`ovUl6Fs`mJP*;BE9b|7CT)6Y@T z6|4~M`t5-gHVr%a9llSbN;K^!$d{S*9R+&6T@@TYdH^on^I^V;T>n<|{|Dq}ch|2L zh)=sRaIC0?4!Lbv&`p$2{)YKkfbluIPx4pLwHev4+2G?xZb$e^9r!%6qhzki{BynlCOOQ+?eWY=C8P4gh^j0Zca!TutfF@Ncz%qlAymZ_k7 zrj!Ds#jyEtKX&UjxBm<5U;ciiHA+iWwCAca_+(TCksGOp;^d(GhN@pHUD6z4HnMt$jaXP1@Y5EO{PHPA5WGV<#blz z8d!2|CtSHKXFpV